Contributed By O’Conor & Power
Trade marks are governed by Trade Mark Law No 22.362 and copyrights are governed by Copyright Law No 11.723. Argentina is not a common law country.
Argentina has ratified of the following treaties:
All of these treaties are self-executive.
Argentina’s legal system allows the protection of collective marks; certification marks, denomination of origin, indication of origin and geographical indications; emblems, as well as well-known trade marks. Argentine Trade Mark Law sets out in Article 1:
“The following can be registered as trade marks to distinguish products and services: one or more words with or without conceptual content; drawings; emblems; monograms; engravings; prints; the stamps; the images; the bands; the colour combinations applied to a particular place on the products or packaging; the wrappings; packaging; the combinations of letters and numbers; the letters and numbers for their special drawing; advertising phrases; reliefs with distinctive capacity and any other sign with such capacity.”
Brands can be traditional or non-traditional. Within traditional marks are wordmarks, labels and figurative marks. Non-traditional marks that can gain protection include tridimensional, combination of colours, position marks, sounds, olfactory, tactile, gustatory, movement, multimedia (movement and sound), hologram, trade dress as well as the shapes of buildings.
Proper names, pseudonyms and portraits may be registered as trade marks only by the physical person themselves or with their consent or that of their heirs up to and including the fourth degree.
A collective mark is a common distinctive sign that identifies products and services provided by enterprises aimed at the development of the social economy. This type of trade mark is governed by Law No 26,355.
Law No 25.380 foresees the protection of geographical names, regulating two categories: Geographical Indication and Denomination of Origin.
Foreign appellations of origin are not registrable as trade marks. The designation of origin is understood as the name of a country, a region, a place or a specific geographical area that serves to designate a product originating from them and whose qualities and characteristics are due exclusively to the geographical environment. An appellation of origin is also considered to refer to a specific geographical area for the purposes of certain products.
Emblems, on the other hand, may be registered as trade marks, although the registration of trade marks, as well as elements of the aforementioned trade marks, of coats of arms, flags and other state emblems of the countries of the Union, official signs and hallmarks of control and guarantee adopted by the member countries of the Paris Convention are forbidden.
Argentina is a member of the Paris Convention and the TRIPS Agreements granting protection to well-known trade marks.
Trade marks must have distinctive character to be registrable. To build the distinctive character of a brand, one should consider, for example, the logo, typography, colours and name, among others.
Acquired distinctiveness is a process that requires time and effort. To determine whether a trade mark has acquired a secondary meaning, it must be demonstrated that, by the mere fact of the trade mark consumers perceive the goods or services in question as coming from a particular origin. To demonstrate that a trade mark has acquired distinctiveness, the applicant must submit evidence, such as:
The trade mark registration grants the owners the exclusive use of the registered trade mark. It also authorises the exercise of all necessary defences to prevent third parties, without authorisation, from marketing identical products or services with the same or similar trade mark, or one that may cause confusion.
These rights are exclusive to the owner; however they are liable to be lost if the trade mark has not been used since the fifth year of registration, by the action of a third party requesting the cancellation of the trade mark on the basis of the lack of use.
In order to maintain the registration of a trade mark, an affidavit of use must be filed indicating that the trade mark has been used; however it is not necessary to accompany evidence of such use.
If a trade mark faces cancellation due to lack of use, the trade mark owner has the burden of proof of said use.
This use must be real, public, consistent and prolonged in the country, even for goods/services other than those distinguished by the trade mark registration, as long as they are related.
Evidence such as links, photographs, publications, packages, labels, advertisements and invoices are admitted in order to demonstrate the use of the brand.
The trade mark ® symbol is only used if the trade mark has been granted.
In Argentina, symbols such as TM and SM are also often used, although the trade mark is not yet registered.
In no case is it mandatory to include these symbols in the application for trade mark registrations, since their use is totally optional.
There are certain trade marks that can be protected under other legal systems such as Copyright and/or Industrial Designs. For example, logos, cartoons or titles of works/series/movies. Surnames can only obtain trade mark and copyright protection by the physical person or with their consent.
In Argentina, the following can be protected by copyright: literary works, musical works, choreographies, graphic or sculptural works, architectural works, computer programs, databases, plastic works, multimedia works and scientific works.
The basic requirements to obtain copyright protection are novelty, authorship and originality.
The author is the person who creates the work, as well as their collaborators. If the work is created by commission, several issues shall be taken into account – eg, if the person hired to create a work can do so thanks to all the tools offered by the employer, the authorship will be the employer’s; if they were only hired to do a specific work but they were not provided with tools for that purpose, the authorship will be of the real creator of the work. However, specific prior agreements may be made clarifying these issues prior to the registration process.
On the other hand, the Argentine copyright law does not provide for creations made by non-human persons as well as by artificial intelligence and there is still no jurisprudence in this regard in the country.
In cases of co-authorship, those who have participated in the creation of the work to be registered shall be taken into account. The main author is defined as the person who carries out the research and writes and edits the manuscript and the co-author is the one who collaborates with the main author and contributes to the work of the manuscript.
The percentages of ownership shall be agreed by the parties.
According to Law No 11,723, the right of ownership of a scientific, literary or artistic work includes for its author the right to dispose, publish, execute, represent, exhibit and translate the same and to adapt it or to authorise its translation and to reproduce it in any manner.
Moral rights in the field of copyright include two specific aspects:
The intellectual property rights over their works correspond to the authors during their lifetime and to their heirs or successors up to 70 years from January 1st of the year following the death of the author.
In the case of collaborative works, this term will begin from January 1st of the year following the death of the last collaborator. For posthumous works, the term of 70 years shall begin to run as from January 1st of the year following the death of the author.
All copyrights will end after the term stipulated.
In Argentina there are Collective Management Societies that administer the rights of the owners and collect royalties for the public performances of the works that are in their repertoire, distributing the income received among their members. These companies can also grant licences and monitor compliance with the contracts they manage.
In Argentina, some of the best-known collective management societies are: ARGENTORES (General Society of Authors of Argentina), SADAIC (Argentine Society of Authors and Composers of Music) and AADI CAPIF (Society of Phonographic Performers and Producers).
The work must be registered before the National Directorate of Copyright in order to enjoy copyright protection. The Directorate will provide the presumption of validity and the possibility of legal action.
The Argentine Copyright Office (DNDA) holds the publicly available register.
Any natural or legal person may be the owner of a copyright. It is necessary for foreign applicants to have a legal representative in the country. Notices and symbols are not mandatory.
The requirements to apply for a copyright application are to pay the government fee, fill out a form with all the data of the owners and send the work to the DNDA. In case the authors wish to make the deposit in custody of the unpublished work, it must be sent by mail or taken to the DNDA in person in a signed envelope at all closing points.
The government fees that must be paid range from ARS600 for unpublished works and from ARS1,100 for works already published.
The DNDA shall reject works that by their nature are not registrable as copyright and works that are detected to have been created by artificial intelligence, as well as those that lack originality.
The resolutions of the DNDA may be appealed in accordance with the provisions of Law No 19,549.
Certain cases, such as titles of movies, books or cartoons, etc, may be protected both as a trade mark and a copyright.
To obtain trade mark rights, the mark must be registered. The registration of a trade mark guarantees the owner ownership of the trade mark. It enables the owner to exercise all the necessary actions to prevent non-authorised third-party use and the marketing of identical or similar goods or services with the same trade mark or using a name so similar that it may create confusion among consumers.
The registration also protects against partial or total imitations, whether of names, words, signs or advertising phrases, as well as their drawings and colours.
The owner may authorise trade mark use by third parties through licence agreements, both exclusive and non-exclusive, sell them in whole or in part for products or obtain credits by offering them as a collateral through a pledge registration.
For the registration of collective marks, a different procedure is applied. This type of trade mark may only be applied for and owned by a single group made up of producers and/or service providers registered in the National Registry of Local Development and Social Economy Effectors.
In Argentina, the body in charge of the registration, administration and trade mark prosecution is the National Institute of Industrial Property (INPI).
The INPI has only one registry; there are no complementary or secondary registers. It has a public database that only allows one to search for an identical trade mark by identical word that “begins with or contains that word”, both current and expired. It also allows searches by headlines.
To this end, the INPI offers word, graphic and phonetic searches for a fee. However, specialised IP firms in the field have in-depth search system software.
It is highly advisable to conduct a search before the filing of trade mark application.
The term of validity of a trade mark is ten years from the date of granting, renewable indefinitely for consecutive periods of ten years. A trade mark can be renewed from six months prior to the date of expiration, up to six months after that date (grace period).
There are two requirements in order to renew the registration of a trade mark: to have filed the Mid-Term Use Affidavit (MTDU) and to file the Sworn Declaration of Use (SDU) declaring the use of the trade mark during the five years prior to its expiration.
In no way is it possible to modify the trade mark at the time of renewal, nor to extend or amend the goods or services protected.
If a trade mark registration has expired, it is not possible to reactivate it, and a new trade mark application must be filed.
In order to apply for a trade mark, it is necessary to fill out an online form, with the information of the applicant and the trade mark, namely: name, class, items to be protected and type. This must be accompanied by the necessary documentation, according to the type of application, for example, the logo if it is a label or a pentagram along with an MP3 file if it is a sound trade mark.
Multi-class applications are not allowed in Argentina.
The official fees for a trade mark application in one class are ARS17,680 – which covers up to 20 goods or services. Each surplus item to be protected costs of ARS200.
Trade marks can be applied for by individuals or legal entities, public entities, or non-profit associations, national or foreign. Foreign companies must act through a patent and trade mark agent or an attorney licensed to practise in Argentina.
Prior use is not a requirement for registration of a trade mark.
The INPI makes a substantive examination of new trade mark applications, where, among other items, it checks whether there is, for the same or related classes, a prior right, namely a previous registration or a pending application in the name of a third party for an identical or very similar trade mark that could cause confusion.
The Trade Mark Office makes such checks regardless of whether or not the mark has received oppositions from third parties. If there is any prior right in force, the Trade Mark Office issues an office action in order for the applicant to answer what it deems necessary to safeguard its trade mark application.
Third parties have the possibility to file an opposition based on their prior rights within 30 calendar days counted as from the publication of the trade mark.
If a trade mark application receives an opposition and then it is maintained through the filing of an additional writ, the administrative opposition resolution procedure is initiated.
The Trade Mark Office may deny an application, even if it has not received oppositions, based on prior rights or other grounds.
An applicant may withdraw a trade mark application by filing a writ. It is not possible to amend, modify or correct a trade mark application unless the change is the actual address of the applicant or a limitation of protection within the same class in which it was applied for. The latter change, if possible, must be requested before the publication of the trade mark in the Official Bulletin.
The division of a trade mark application is not possible in Argentina.
Mistakes that are minor, such as the address, can be changed by filing a writ. Substantially incorrect information, such as the incorrect class, may result in an office action or even the denial of the application.
The Trade Mark Office may reject a trade mark application if it considers that it is infringing the prohibitions established by the Argentine Trade Mark Law, as follows:
Upon this type of resolution, the applicant may file an appeal with the Trade Mark Office within ten working days counted as from the official notification. If the appeal is rejected, a further appeal may be filed for the final decision of the President of the INPI.
Argentina is not a member of the Madrid System.
Any third party with a legitimate interest may file an opposition within 30 days from the publication of the trade mark in the Official Bulletin.
It is not possible to request extensions or time to file an opposition.
There are two moments of “reflection to reach an amicable solution”. The first one is after the official notification of the opposition, for a term of three months. The second one, optional, is requested by means of a joint brief filed by the parties during the process of administrative resolution of the opposition, which suspends all deadlines for a period of 30 calendar days.
Oppositions and/or cancellations may be based on the rules as foreseen in the Trade Mark Law, in Articles 2, 3, 24 and 26.
The existing remedies are expiration in cases of non-use and nullity in cases of defects.
Different remedies may be filed at the Trade Mark Office to re-examine a decision: reconsideration, hierarchical and appeal.
Any third party may file an opposition on the basis of the legal prohibitions of registrability set forth in the Trade Mark Law. One does not necessarily have to be the owner of a trade mark application or trade mark registration, but may also oppose on the basis of trade marks abroad, trade marks used or on the basis of a trade name (based on the Paris Convention and the TRIPS Agreement).
In order to file an opposition, you do not need an attorney. However, to initiate the administrative resolution of oppositions, representation is necessary.
The cost to file an opposition with the Trade Mark Office is ARS17,680 and trade mark maintenance costs are ARS88,400. Lawyers’ fees will vary according to experience and prestige.
A revocation or nullity action may be filed by third parties with a legitimate interest or ex officio by the Trade Mark Office.
Once the trade mark is published in the Official Bulletin, third parties have 30 calendar days to file an opposition. The applicant is officially notified and has a term of three months to obtain an amicable withdrawal of the objection
At the end of this period, if the opposition has not been withdrawn, the Trade Mark Office will notify the opponent to maintain the opposition within 15 working days, paying an additional fee, expanding on the grounds and providing the proof it deems necessary.
If the opposition is not maintained, the trade mark application returns to substantive examination by the Trade Mark Office.
Subsequently, the Trade Mark Office notifies the applicant only of the maintained oppositions and grants the applicant a term of 15 working days to pay the fee corresponding to the opposition resolution, and also to answer each maintenance, providing the proof they consider necessary.
Acceptable proof includes documentary evidence of previous trade mark registrations both in Argentina and abroad and proof of use, such as brochures, invoices and related links.
Further, there is a period of 40 days to produce the accompanying proof and the Trade Mark Office issues an opinion on this proof, informing which is accepted and which is denied.
There is then a period of ten working days to file a voluntary writ containing the final arguments; at this time it is also possible to request the suspension of deadlines to reach an amicable agreement.
None of these deadlines can be extended.
Finally, if the opposition has not yet been withdrawn, the Trade Mark Office will issue its decision, informing whether it was well-founded or ill founded.
Likewise, together with the maintenance or opposition process, the parties may file a cancellation or nullity action.
Partial cancellations and nullities are acceptable in Argentina.
According to Section 17 of the Trade Mark Law, the resolutions on oppositions issued by the National Directorate of Trade Marks shall only be subject to direct appeal before the National Chamber of Appeals in Civil and Commercial Federal Matters within 30 working days as from their official notification. The appeal shall be filed with the National Institute of Industrial Property, which shall forward it to the courts under the conditions set forth in the corresponding regulations.
Amendment is not possible in revocation/cancellation proceedings.
Decisions in infringement and revocation cases are processed separately since their purposes are different. Expiration arises due to lack of use and infringement looks at the damage caused. The deadlines are also different since they are different procedures.
In the event of a fraudulent application, a nullity procedure may be initiated.
There is no way to suspend an application when investigation results are pending.
The consequences for an applicant if it is found that it fraudulently filed an application is the nullity of the trade mark.
Assignment of a trade mark:
Assignments can be partial or total.
In the event of death, the rights are transferable.
A trade mark licence can be granted through donation, free or onerous transfer, trust, transfer of goodwill, allocation of assets, merger or transformation of companies or judicial auction. Inheritance will or legacy are also registered due to death.
The licences are for an agreed term.
Applications can also be licensed.
Recording the assignment is not mandatory. However, it must be registered before the Trade Mark Office to be valid against third parties. For registration purposes, a form with the original assignment (or a certified copy of it) as well as the original certificate of registration (or an official certified copy) must be submitted.
The Trade Mark Law No 22,362 defines what actions can be taken in case of infringement, and clarifies that civil actions became due three years after they took place or one year from the time the infringement was known. This is not the case for criminal actions or for copyright infringements, which do not have a specific term.
Trade Mark Law No 22,362 establishes that the counterfeiting or fraudulent imitation of a registered trade mark is punishable by imprisonment for a period of three to 6 six years and a fine. In addition, the injured party may choose to (i) confiscate and sell the goods and other elements with the infringing trade mark; or destroy the infringing marks and designations and all the elements that carry them, if they cannot be separated from the product itself. The trade mark must be registered in order for these actions to be carried out.
Copyright Law No 11,723 establishes that non-compliance with intellectual property obligations is punishable with a fine. Copyright infringement is considered a criminal offence and is punishable by fines, confiscation of property and imprisonment. In the event of plagiarism, provisional and precautionary measures may be filed as well as civil or commercial lawsuits.
The elements of the different types of infringement are compared based on the infringer’s intent, trade mark use, likelihood of confusion, and damage to the trade mark owner’s reputation. Direct infringement is characterised by the use of the registered trade mark in a direct manner and with the intention of confusing, while indirect infringement is characterised by the use of a similar trade mark and the likelihood of confusion. Contributory infringement is characterised by the use of the mark in different markets and the likelihood of confusion, and infringement by omission is characterised by non-use of the mark and the likelihood of confusion.
Trade mark infringements take place upon:
Copyright infringement takes place upon:
In order for an action for infringement of industrial or intellectual property to be successful, the following elements must be proven:
In Argentina, the elements of the different types of infringement may be considered as follows.
There are several trade mark claims that can be filed, in addition to direct and indirect infringement.
All of these claims are set forth in the following statutes:
In determining whether the use of a trade mark or copyright constitutes infringement, the following factors must be considered:
These factors are established by law, and are regulated in the following laws:
In order to proceed with the filing of a lawsuit, the following is required:
Certain restrictions limiting the ability of the trade mark or copyright owner to enforce their right against third parties are regulated by the following laws:
Some of the most common restrictions are:
It is worth highlighting that prerequisites may vary depending on the specific circumstances of each case.
In the case of trade mark infringements, the actions will be brought before the Federal Criminal and Correctional Court for criminal actions, and before the Federal Civil and Commercial Court for civil actions
Please bear in mind that trade mark and copyright cases fall under Federal courts, as established by Article 17 of the National Constitution.
Before initiating a legal action, mandatory pre-judicial mediation must be complied with. It is also common that prior to the mediation there is an exchange of cease-and-desist letters. The parties must always, in any type of judicial litigation and even before the administrative authorities in charge of regulating the rights of Industrial Property (INPI, DNDA, etc), be represented by an attorney.
Owners of foreign trade marks or copyrights can file infringement lawsuits. It is essential and advisable that they have the trade mark or work registered in Argentina.
The merely declaratory action is regulated as the means to obtain the court’s declaration on:
The legal system requires three presuppositions for the action to be admissible:
For reasons of equity and contrary to the precautionary measures that the plaintiff may request, it is justified that the defendant does not bear the damages when, once the merits of the matter are decided, it is resolved that there was no violation of the intellectual rights of another person.
The TRIPS Agreement, which is applicable in Argentina, provides that in cases where interim measures are instigated or expire by the action or omission of the complainant, or in those cases where it is subsequently determined that there has been no infringement or threat of infringement of an intellectual property right, the judicial authorities shall be empowered to order the complainant, at the request of the respondent, to give the defendant adequate compensation for any damage caused by these measures. The post of a bond or an equivalent guarantee that is sufficient to protect the defendant and prevent abuse is provided.
There are alternative ways to resolve small trade mark or copyright claims, namely mediation and arbitration.
The fora hearing these cases are the Mediation and Arbitration Centre of the Buenos Aires Chamber of Commerce and small cause courts.
The legal bodies hearing the claims are:
Decisions by trade mark or copyright offices can have significant effects on infringement actions, as follows:
In Argentina, civil courts may consider the decisions of trade mark or copyright offices as evidence in the infringement action. However, civil courts are not bound by these decisions and can make their own decisions based on the evidence filed in the case.
In Argentina, a counterfeit trade mark or copyright counterfeit refers to the reproduction, distribution, or commercialisation of products or works that infringe the intellectual property rights of a trade mark or copyright owner, without their authorisation or consent.
Trade mark and copyright counterfeiting is a criminal offence in Argentina, and is regulated by the Trade Marks and Designations Law (Law No 22,362) and the Copyright Law (Law No 11,723).
In Argentina, there are several procedures and remedies to address trade mark and copyright counterfeiting, including:
There are several special laws that address trade mark and copyright counterfeiting, including:
In Argentina, a party may be subject to criminal liability for counterfeiting if it is proven that it has committed a trade mark or copyright counterfeiting offence. Criminal penalties may include:
Smuggling refers to the import, export or movement of prohibited or restricted goods without payment of the corresponding customs duties or without complying with established legal requirements. Smuggling can include the introduction of goods that are counterfeit, pirated or infringe intellectual property rights.
Procedures and Remedies
Parties that may be subject to criminal liability:
There are special procedural provisions for trade mark and copyright court proceedings.
The courts dealing with trade marks and copyright matters are the National Courts of First Instance in Federal Civil and Commercial Matters.
Special Procedure
The procedure for trade mark and copyright cases is special and is governed by the Trade Marks and Designations Law (Law No 22,362) and the Copyright Law (Law No 11,723).
Experts
In cases of copyright and trade marks, experts may be appointed to issue opinions on technical issues related to the matter.
Evidence
In copyright and trade mark cases, documentary, testimonial and expert evidence may be submitted to prove infringement or validity of the trade mark or copyright.
Mediation
Mediation hearings may be applicable to resolve disputes related to trade marks and copyrights.
Appeals
Appeals may be filed against court decisions in trade mark and copyright matters.
The parties cannot directly influence on the final decision of the court.
There are several courts specialising in intellectual property, such as the:
In Argentina, when the owner of a trade mark or copyright is the owner of a registration, they receive several judicial benefits, such as:
Regarding the similarity of goods and services, Argentine law establishes that a trade mark will be considered similar to another if:
As for the period of time after which certain defences are not available, Argentine law provides that:
The typical costs of pursuing a trade mark or copyright infringement action in the first instance can vary depending on several factors, such as the complexity of the case, the amount of evidence and witnesses, etc. Below are some of the typical costs and factors that significantly influence the expected costs:
Typical costs:
Factors that significantly influence the expected costs:
There are several defences to trade mark infringement, which can be classified into two categories: absolute defences and relative defences. Some of the most common defences are as follows.
Absolute Defences
Priority
The priority defence is based on the fact that the defendant registered their trade mark before the plaintiff. In order for this defence to be valid, the defendant must show that their trade mark was registered prior to the plaintiff’s trade mark.
Abandonment
The abandonment defence is based on the plaintiff having abandoned their trade mark, meaning that they have not used it for an extended period of time. For this defence to be valid, the defendant must show that the plaintiff has not used their trade mark for at least five years.
Expiration
The revocation defence is based on the fact that the registration of the plaintiff’s trade mark has expired. In order for this defence to be valid, the defendant must show that the plaintiff’s trade mark registration has expired.
Relative Defences
Relative defences include:
In Argentina, these defences are recognised by law and can be invoked in a trade mark infringement lawsuit. The Trade Marks and Designations Law (Law No 22,362) and the Copyright Law (Law No 11,723) establish the defences that can be invoked in a lawsuit for trade mark and copyright infringement.
Argentina recognises an exception to copyright infringement. The Copyright Law (Law No 11,723) establishes in its Article 32 that the use of a work protected by copyright for the purposes of criticism, commentary, news, teaching, research or study will not be considered a copyright infringement, as long as the source and the name of the author are mentioned, and that the use is reasonable and does not affect the normal exploitation of the work.
The Supreme Court of Justice has also established in several rulings that satire and parody can be considered as an exception to copyright infringement, as long as certain requirements are met, such as:
Argentina recognises several exceptions to trade mark infringement. Article 12 of the Trade Mark and Designation Law (Law No 22,362) establishes that the use of a trade mark will not be considered a trade mark infringement in the following cases:
In addition, the Supreme Court of Justice has established in several rulings that the use of a registered trade mark can be considered as an exception to trade mark infringement if certain requirements are met, such as:
Argentina has adopted the international exhaustion system. Consequently, it could be argued that there is no legal framework by which the entry into the country of genuine products introduced into the international market through their owner or with their consent can be prevented. As they are legitimate goods, the import could not be classified as counterfeit or fraudulent imitation. Likewise, as it consists of goods acquired from the trade mark owner or from its licensees, distributors or dealers, it could not be classified as the use of another person’s trade mark without authorisation or marketing of counterfeit products.
Argentine jurisprudence has been inclined to adopt the criterion of international exhaustion. This implies that when the owner of the trade mark has placed the goods bearing the trade mark on the market in Argentina and abroad, the owner has been denied preventing the entry and circulation of genuine merchandise identified as legitimate merchandise introduced by third parties outside the official distribution network.
There are certain circumstances that entitle the owner of a trade mark to take legal action when the intermediary subject performs acts that are incompatible with the functions of the trade marks, such as those guaranteeing origin and quality. In these cases, exhaustion does not occur, even if the product has been placed on the market by the trade mark owner or through a third party with their authorisation.
In Argentina, precautionary measures are legal instruments that allow the owner of a trade mark or copyright to request the judge to order measures to prevent or avoid irreparable or irreversible damage while the main dispute is being resolved. The following precautionary measures are available:
The judge has discretion to order injunctive relief, but must consider the following factors:
Precautionary measures will be granted in the following circumstances:
The judge will consider the following factors when evaluating the request for the granting of an injunctive relief.
To receive an injunction in Argentina, the owner of a trade mark or copyright must demonstrate irreparable harm, a likelihood of success, urgency and a balance of difficulties. On the other hand, the defendant may oppose the injunction on the grounds of common defences, delays, issues of fairness, lack of evidence, or abuse of rights.
A trade mark or copyright defendant may object to an injunction on the following grounds:
As for specific defences, the defendant may plead:
Trade mark or copyright holders can seek various monetary remedies to be compensated for damages caused by the infringement of their rights. Some of the monetary remedies available are:
The judge has discretion to order remedies. Please refer to 10.1 Injunctive Remedies.
In Argentina, there are specific rules and restrictions on the type and amount of damages awarded in trade mark or copyright infringement cases. Damages are calculated based on the actual loss suffered by the trade mark or copyright owner, and different methods are applied to calculate damages, such as lost sales, decreased reputation, and lost business opportunities.
Some of the most important rules and restrictions are:
As for the way in which damages are calculated, different methods are used, such as:
The responsibility to pay the costs of litigation for trade mark and copyright claims is determined in accordance with the rules of the National Civil and Commercial Procedure Code and the Trade Mark and Designation Law.
The owner of a trade mark or copyright may seek relief without notice from the defendant in certain circumstances, such as when injunctive relief is requested. However, in general, prior notification to the defendant is required, which may be in person, by mail or by telegram, and must contain the elements established in the National Civil and Commercial Procedure Code.
Argentina provides for customs embargo on counterfeits and parallel imports. The relevant process is described below.
The Customs Entry Alert is a system implemented by the Customs Collection and Control Agency (ARCA) in Argentina, which allows registered trade mark owners to receive information about imported merchandise that bears their brand before they are released into the market by the customs officials. This gives them the opportunity to anticipate the entry of counterfeit products and obtain valuable information on parallel imports of genuine merchandise.
Once the trade mark is registered with the Alert Entry System, the merchandise identified with the trade mark is automatically blocked by Customs for three days to allow the trade mark owner to inspect the same. The owner of the trade mark and the persons authorised by them are exempt from the aforementioned automatic blocking.
To register in the system, trade mark owners must complete Form OM 2270 and submit the same to the Customs Trade Mark Fraud Division, along with the necessary documentation, such as the trade mark registration certificate, power of attorney to an authorised third party, and the ID of the owner and representative, among others.
Registration in the system has a validity period of two years, extendable for similar periods at the request of the interested party. Once this period has expired, the trade mark in question must be renewed by its owner and/or representative within 30 days prior to its expiry.
The Customs Alert Entry System has proven to be effective in the fight against counterfeiting and parallel imports, as it allows trade mark owners to take measures to protect their rights and prevent counterfeit products from entering the country.
Decisions for infringement of rights and/or author’s rights may be appealed.
The competent body for the filing of appeals in this matter is the National Court of Appeals in Federal Civil and Commercial Matters.
The appeal must be filed with the judge or court that issued the contested judgment within ten working days of the official notification of the same.
In Argentina, you can appeal against:
As long as there is capacity to appeal, legitimate interest and the reasons for the appeal are expressed.
The resolution time can vary in each particular case and depending on the complexities of the matter, and sn average of between 12 and 18 months is estimated.
An important issue that occurred recently in Argentina is that the concept of “reproduction in public spaces” of works registered in copyright was amended, now considering that music or films played at a private event, party, disco or hotel should not pay copyright tax to the collective management society that is the Argentine Society of Music Authors and Composers (SADAIC), since it is considered a private sphere and not a public one as it was considered before.
In Argentina there is still no law that regulates artificial intelligence; however there are many bills under analysis.
Jurisprudence from other countries will be cited in the event that there is no Argentine judicial ruling that applies to the case. In any case, the latter is not binding.
In connection with e-commerce, it is useful to mention the case of MercadoLibre, an e-commerce platform for buying and selling products and services, by which trade marks, copyrights or industrial models and designs may be included in their monitor system granting protection so as to ensure to the trade mark owner that no one, but its official store, commercialises the products within the platform, also preventing the sale of counterfeited goods.
Another example is Youtube; the videos that are published on the platform must not violate copyright and in case this happens, the published video is automatically deleted.
San Martín 663, Piso 9
Buenos Aires
C1004AAM
Argentina
+54 11 4311 2740
+ 54 11 5368 7192/3
ocp@oconorpower.com.ar www.oconorpower.com.ar