Contributed By Odvetniška družba Andrić
The main sources of real estate law in Republic of Slovenia are the Law of Property Code, the Building Act, the Spatial Management Act, the Code of Obligations and the Land Register Act.
Over the course of the last 12 months, the prices in the real estate market have risen somewhat due to the general improvement of the economic situation in Slovenia and the consequential increase of demand. Due to some financial restructuring operations concerning real estate conglomerates, there has also been an increase in the quantity and scope of investments, especially in the area of warehousing and residential developments, while the market has also seen an increase in public investments.
There is currently no proposal that would significantly impact real estate investment, ownership or development. However, it must be noted that, although the abovementioned statutes that entered into force in June 2018 were supposedly adopted with the intention of simplifying and expediting the adoption and obtainment of spatial acts, construction and fit-for-use permits (by introducing so-called integrated procedures), it is unclear, given the fact that that the new legislation has not yet been properly tested in practice for a significant period, whether the newly adopted legislation will, in fact, achieve the goals set out in the legislation proposal.
Furthermore, it must be noted that, in December 2013, the National Assembly of the Republic of Slovenia adopted the Real Estate Tax Act, which levied on the owners of real estate an annual tax calculated on the basis of the valuation assessed by the state administration pursuant to the Mass Valuation of Immovable Property Act. The adoption of said statute has been greeted with great disapproval by the general public, as well as the professional public; soon thereafter, a procedure for the review of the constitutionality of said statute was initiated before the Constitutional Court, which repealed the statute in question, mainly due to it being insufficiently clear and precise, and due to it unreasonably applying different tax rates in similar taxable situations. In other words, the Constitutional Court did not repeal the statute because the imposition of a real estate tax would be unconstitutional, but mainly because the statute in the wording in which it was adopted did not meet the clarity and precision of tax-imposing provision requirements of the Constitution of the Republic of Slovenia, which means that such a tax could still be levied in the future.
In the aftermath of the repeal of the Real Estate Tax Act, the Government of the Republic of Slovenia issued an official statement that the wording of the statute would be amended and that the real estate tax would be enacted sooner rather than later. The imposition of such a tax would greatly limit the attractiveness of owning real estate in Slovenia
The full list of property rights that can be acquired are listed by the Law of Property Code which provides for the following categories of property rights: ownership right (the most common as an ownership of a plot of land and the pertaining buildings, if not divided into individually owned building units under a strata-title regime), lien, easement, building right (right to erect and own a building on or under a plot of a land for a maximum of 99 years) and land charge (right to demand the performance of certain periodical acts or services from the real estate owner).
Transfer and acquisition of property, as well as formal contract-related requirements are primarily regulated by the Law of Property Code, the Code of Obligations and the Land Registry Act. Some other restrictions – for example, pre-emption rights of municipalities or administrative approvals – can be found throughout the legislation if the property that is the subject of transaction meets certain statutorily laid-down criteria. For example, if the intended use of a certain piece of land is agricultural, the pre-emptive right-related provisions of the Agricultural Land Act must be observed. Similarly, if a certain piece of land is located within the area deemed by the respective municipality of such importance that a statutory pre-emptive right is instituted in favour of such municipality, the approval or waiver of pre-emptive right by such municipality must be obtained prior to the conclusion of the real estate transfer contract. Such rights of pre-emption are laid down also with respect to real estate representing forests, bodies of water, cultural heritage, nature-preservation or state-defence-related sites, etc.
Ownership of real estate is transferred from the transferor to the transferee by way of registration in the electronically maintained Land Registry, with the Land Registry permission issued by the transferor being a necessary prerequisite for such registration. In order for a Land Registry permission to be registered with the Land Registry, the parties must first conclude an appropriate written contract and fulfil all of the administrative and tax-related requirements. All transfers, as well as the underlying contracts and Land Registry permissions, are recorded in the publicly accessible Land Registry.
Given the fact that the Land Registry is held electronically and is publicly accessible and that the person relying on the information contained in the Land Registry may not suffer negative consequences as a result of relying on such information, title insurance is not common. Any potential defects or problems relating to the ownership of real property are usually eliminated in the due diligence process and additionally contractually regulated between the contracting parties themselves.
A transferee typically commissions an expert legal advisor to conduct a thorough due diligence process regarding the property in question. Due diligence is done primarily by examining the electronically held and publicly accessible records (Land Registry, Land Cadastre, Building Cadastre, etc) and, if necessary, by co-operating with other governmental or local bodies (eg, to verify that the real estate in question is not subject of any restitution or expropriation procedures).
The statute contains only framework representations and warranties, which is why appropriate representations and warranties are typically given in the sale and purchase contract, primarily with regard to the absence of any rights of third persons to the subject of the contract (the seller usually guarantees that the current legal state of the real estate, as evident from the Land Registry, is accurate), while the seller typically provides also additional representations and warranties in connection with the factual state of the real estate, as well as taxes and other public duties payable with respect to the real estate. In the case of the seller’s misrepresentation, a buyer is entitled to demand that the seller remedy the breach at its own expense, make a proportionate reduction of the purchase price or unilaterally rescind the contract and claim reimbursement for any damages suffered.
The most important areas of law for an investor are construction law, property law, spatial planning and zoning law, real estate tax law and environmental protection law.
Under the Environmental Protection Act, the 'polluter pays' principle applies. This means that polluter is responsible for the elimination of any excessive pollutants and related consequences and is liable for all costs of measures taken in order to prevent or reduce pollution or environmental risk. Allocation of liability in respect of environmental clean-up is commonly regulated by the contract, as typically one of the representations and warranties of the seller is a declaration that the object of sale is free from any contaminants. Should such a declaration of the seller prove to be false and it is established that the object of sale is encumbered with a factual defect (contamination), the buyer is entitled to demand that the seller remedy the breach at its own expense, demand a proportionate reduction of the purchase price or withdraw from the contract.
The state and local authorities regulate the spatial planning, development and use of real estate and determine the use of specific areas of land. A buyer can obtain information concerning the permitted uses of land from the competent local authorities. With regard to specific development agreements, it must be noted that, under the current legislations, such agreements are limited only to projects carried out in the public interest from June 2018 onwards.
Compulsory purchase of real estate or expropriation is only permitted if it is required for the public benefit (with the term ‘public benefit’ being defined by different statutes) and this benefit cannot be achieved without it. Generally, a compulsory purchase procedure is allowed after a compulsory beneficiary has failed to negotiate a voluntary purchase from the owner of the property. Owners and tenants are eligible for compensation established by a certified appraiser. However, an agreement on compensation is also possible. Decisions on compulsory purchase can be challenged in court.
Asset deals concerning real estate are usually taxed by the 2% Real Property Transaction Act, payable by the seller – however, the parties may agree that such tax be borne by the buyer. If certain specific conditions are met, such transactions may also be taxed in accordance with VAT, under the Value Added Tax Act (22%, although tax-neutral if both parties are subject to VAT). Obligations concerning taxation must be fulfilled prior to registration in the Land Registry. In the case of share deals, the buyer enters into the position of the owner of real estate, which is why such transaction is not viewed as a real estate transfer; however, share deals may be subject to the payment of Corporate Income Tax, currently amounting to 19%. The contracting parties are free to agree on who bears the liabilities for taxes and duties in relation to the real estate.
There are no legal restrictions for legal entities and natural persons from EU member states, while legal entities and natural persons from non-EU countries are allowed to acquire real estate only under the condition of reciprocity – ie, if Slovenian legal entities and natural persons are allowed to acquire real estate in that country of origin.
Acquisitions of commercial real estate are generally financed by both equity and debt. An investor usually has to provide sufficient equity to acquire debt financing from a bank or any other type of lending institution.
The most common security instrument available to lenders (usually financing banks) is a mortgage. Other types of security instruments usually include liens on movable property or a company’s shares and other intangible assets (such as intellectual property rights), mother company guarantees, bills of exchange, sureties and other personal guarantees. Also quite commonly used is a security assignment of all receivables of the borrower stemming from its bank accounts, insurance policies or receivables held against the tenants. The method of creating and perfecting a security interest in real estate differs, depending on the nature of the security instrument. For example, a mortgage and a lien on the company’s shares must both be registered in the Land Registry and the Court Registry respectively, which is why such agreements are usually concluded in the form of a notarial deed. The agreements granting a non-possessory lien on movable property must also be concluded in the form of a notarial deed. Some forms of liens on movable property (that can be identified through an ID designation, such as motor vehicles, inventories and equipment) must also be registered in the registry of non-possessory liens. For other types of security instruments, written form is generally sufficient.
There are no restrictions on granting security over real estate to foreign lenders. However, if such a lender wishes to obtain the types of security instruments that must be entered into the appropriate public registries, it must first obtain a tax ID number and an identification number for registration purposes. Liens are commonly instituted on the basis of agreements entered into in the form of a notarial deed. However, assignment of security instruments is only possible together with the underlying loan or claim.
There is no tax that would have to be paid on the granting and enforcement of security over real estate, with the exception that the lender is obliged to pay the notarisation and registration fees in order to achieve Land Registry registration of security.
There are no legal rules or requirements to be complied with before an entity can establish a valid security instrument over its real estate (apart from being a lawful owner), per se. Restrictions could potentially be contained in the entity's memorandum of association or in the event of the entity's insolvency (in such case, legal transactions establishing security interests might be challengeable).
If a borrower is in default, a lender generally must file a lawsuit and obtain an enforceable judgment in a litigation proceeding in order to initiate an enforcement proceeding against a debtor and foreclose on the debtor’s assets. In order to avoid costly and time-consuming litigation proceedings, loan agreements are usually entered into in the form of a directly enforceable notarial deed that grants the lender the right to file for immediate enforcement and foreclosure. The parties can agree that the lender is entitled to assert this right in respect of any kind of obligation defined in such a notarial deed, but the most common type of obligation that is the catalyst for foreclosure is the default in payment of monetary obligations. Slovenian law also allows the parties to agree that the creditor itself is entitled to sell the pledged movable property extrajudicially without having to obtain a writ of enforcement against the debtor. There are no restrictions as to which type of legal remedy may be brought by the lender in the case of default by the borrower.
As regards priority among various interests in the estate, a ranking order is established and published in the Land Registry in accordance with the prior in tempore potior in iure principle. The right that was entered into the Land Registry first has priority over all subsequently entered rights; however, the holders of such rights may agree otherwise, provided that such an agreement is also entered and published in the Land Registry.
The Slovenian law enforces the 'polluter pays' principle, which means that the lender could only be liable for the pollution it caused itself.
In case the borrower becomes insolvent, any security interests created by a borrower could be void if the provisions of Financial Operations, Insolvency Proceedings and Compulsory Winding-up Act are met. The security interest could be void if such security interest was created 12 or 36 months (depending on whether the legal transaction was onerous or gratuitous) prior to the beginning of the bankruptcy proceeding against the borrower, in the so-called contestability period, and under the condition that such security interest caused a decrease in the value of the insolvent debtor's assets (causing the other creditors to obtain a smaller repayment portion in the insolvency procedure) or more favourable payment conditions than the other creditors and if the lender knew or ought to know, at the moment of the conclusion of the transaction, that the debtor is insolvent.
Based on the fact that the LIBOR index is not frequently in use as a benchmark rate offered to the borrowers in Slovenia, any significant consequences are not expected for the general positions of the borrowers in current and future real estate projects. In addition to this, no legal source providing legal consequences of the expiry of the LIBOR index was adopted.
Spatial planning, development, construction and use of real estate are regulated by the state and local authorities through spatial development plans which determine the general use of specific areas of land. Control is exercised in the construction permit obtainment procedures, as the competent authorities are obliged to reject the request for the issue of a construction permit if the intended construction contravenes the provisions of the applicable spatial plan.
The design, appearance and method of construction of new buildings or refurbishment of an existing building are governed by the Construction Act and the Spatial Management Act, which, in conjunction with each other, set forth that construction is generally only allowed after acquiring a construction permit. After the issue of a construction permit, the building inspectors are competent to conduct supervision in order to ensure that the actual construction does not derogate from the construction permit.
Regulation and development of intended use of real property is hierarchical, which means that, at state level, the Government of the Republic of Slovenia is the competent authority that decides on the general land use strategy. At the regional and municipal level, the local self-governing communities (for example, municipalities) are competent to adopt detailed spatial plans which must not, however, contravene the hierarchically higher legal acts.
An investor has to obtain a construction permit before starting the construction. The construction permit is issued in an administrative procedure by the competent administrative unit upon the investor's request and after examining the submitted documentation and whether the intended construction is in line with the applicable spatial regulations. In such administrative procedure, any third party with appropriate legal interest (eg, parties whose rights or benefits could be affected by the intended construction) has the right to participate and potentially file objections against the intended construction.
The investor and/or the third parties with appropriate legal interest have a right to an appeal against any decision of the competent authority issued in a construction permit-related procedure.
Under the current legislation, specific agreements with local or governmental authorities or agencies or utility suppliers are possible, but are limited to the construction of public utility infrastructure and, from June 2018 onwards, limited only to projects carried out in the public interest.
Restrictions on development and designated use are enforced by a separate state authority (ie, the Inspectorate for the Environment and Spatial Planning), which has the power to initiate an inspection procedure and demand that the owner/investor rectify any established breaches, including demolition of illegal structures. Should the owner/investor not comply with the decrees issued by the Inspectorate, the Inspectorate has the option to enforce such decrees by force and at the expense of the owner/investor.
Investment entities can take several different legal forms. Those forms are unlimited liability company (d.n.o.), limited partnership (k.d.), limited liability company (d.o.o.), public limited company (d.d.) or partnership limited by shares (k.d.d.). The best shield for ultimate owners is the limited liability company as a vehicle for real estate ownership. All entities are required to pay taxes and fees when acquiring real estate. The most common form of entity used by foreign investors is the limited liability company (d.o.o.).
The main division can be made between limited liability companies and unlimited liability companies.
A limited liability company can be formed by only one shareholder, individual or legal entity, has a simple organisational structure that can be modified according to the investor’s needs and generally shields the shareholders from liability for actions of the company or its debts. The organisational formalities for creating a limited liability company are provided in the Companies Act. A company can be established by one or more shareholders by adopting the articles of association, wherein the company name, seat, objectives, duration of the company (if established for a fixed period of time), and the amount of share capital are set forth. The minimum required share capital is EUR7,500 and can be paid in cash or by in-kind contribution. The profit of the company is generally subject to taxation in Slovenia, unless the provisions of the Corporate Income Tax Act determine otherwise.
A limited partnership can be formed by at least two partners, whereas at least one of the partners has to be liable without limitation, and with all of its property. In other aspects, the provisions regulating limited liability companies generally apply.
The minimum share capital for the limited liability company is EUR7,500. There are no minimum capital requirements for unlimited liability companies and limited partnerships, while in the case of a public limited company the minimum share capital is EUR25,000, the same as for the partnership limited by shares.
There are no special governance requirements, apart from the general requirement of acting as a prudent businessperson.
It is impossible to provide even an approximate cost of maintenance and accounting for a certain legal entity. However, it could be stated that a single-shareholder limited liability company, is, in general, the cheapest to maintain.
A person may occupy and use real estate for a limited period of time without buying it on a number of legal bases, such as a building right (which is treated very similarly to ownership) or some forms of personal easements; the most commonly used legal transaction to this effect is the lease agreement.
Slovenian law differs between ordinary leases, residential leases, leases of commercial premises and leases of agricultural land. Ordinary lease agreements are generally governed by the framework provisions of the Code of Obligations; however, in the case of residential, commercial and agricultural leases, mandatory provisions of the Housing Act, Commercial Buildings and Commercial Premises Act and Agricultural Land Act must be observed respectively. The most notable restrictions of the abovementioned statutes include the prohibition of subletting without the consent of the lessor, the fact that the lease agreement for commercial premises may only be terminated in a time-consuming court proceeding, and that the lease agreement for agricultural land may only be concluded for a minimum of ten years and must be registered in the Land Registry.
Rents or lease terms are, in principle, freely negotiable, with the exception of limits mentioned in the preceding point and some specific and untypical mandatory provisions that may not be derogated from.
The length of lease terms for commercial premises is freely negotiable, with the parties often opting for a one to ten-year fixed term, as in the case of an indefinite term, the termination of the lease contract and vacation of the premises is somewhat time-consuming and costly due to the antiquated legislation regulating the lease of commercial premises.
Contractual parties can voluntary regulate their rights and obligations. However, it is common for the tenants to be responsible for minor maintenance-related tasks and the payment of operating costs, while the landlord is usually responsible for investment maintenance and major repair.
Rent payments are usually made monthly, but can be agreed differently by the parties.
The amount of rent will remain the same for the duration of the lease, unless the parties change it by an annex to the lease contract or by including the so-called indexation clause, causing the amount of rent to be harmonised with the relevant index.
Given the fact that the rent is determined in the lease agreement – which must be in written form – any changes in rent generally require a written annex to the lease agreement.
VAT is generally not payable on rent, but the parties may opt-in to the VAT system by issuing appropriate statements to the Tax Authority.
At the conclusion of the lease agreement, it is common for the landlord to demand that the tenant pay a security deposit or procure a bank guarantee as security for the fulfillment of its obligations under the lease contract.
Costs of maintenance and repair of common areas used by several tenants are usually divided between the tenants, taking into account their proportional shares.
Costs of utilities and telecommunications which serve a property occupied by several tenants are usually divided between the tenants, taking into account their proportional shares, unless the property enables individual procurement and payment of these services.
The obligation to insure the subject of a lease is usually transferred onto the tenant. Most commonly required is property and civil liability insurance which cover insurance events stated in the insurance contract, usually damage caused by fire, wind, storm, flood, hail, lightning, etc.
It is common for the landlord to impose rules on how the real estate is to be used. There are no specific statutory regulations concerning this matter, which is why it is commonly regulated in the contract between the landlord and the tenant.
During the lease, the tenant is not permitted to alter or improve the real estate without a prior consent of the landlord, unless otherwise agreed in the contract.
There are specific provisions in the Housing Act, Commercial Buildings and Commercial Premises Act and Agricultural Land Act that, in general, provide for increased protection of tenants, minimum duration of the lease, restrictions on the use of rented property, etc.
In case of the tenant’s insolvency, the landlord is entitled to terminate the contract if such entitlement is provided in the lease contract or according to the provisions of the Financial Operations, Insolvency Proceedings and Compulsory Dissolution Act. If the contract is not terminated, the lender can collect rents during the bankruptcy proceedings.
It is common in Slovenia to agree on security deposits or other instruments of collateral when concluding a lease agreement. Security instruments include bank guarantees, letters of credit, surety, parent company guarantee, bills of exchange and, most commonly, a security cash deposit given to the landlord at the beginning of the lease.
In general, the tenant does not have a right to occupy the relevant real estate after the expiration or termination of a lease, but this does not mean that the tenant will necessarily voluntarily vacate the premises as agreed. If after the expiry of the lease, the tenant continues to use the premises and the landlord does not object to it, it shall be deemed that the lease has been tacitly prolonged for an indefinite time. If the landlord wants to have the premises vacated and the tenant resists, the landlord must obtain a judgment in a litigious procedure instructing the tenant to vacate the premises and, if the tenant still resists, enforce the judgment in an enforcement procedure. The litigious procedure step may be avoided and the vacation of premises expedited if the lease agreement is entered into in the form of a directly enforceable notarial deed representing the enforcement title for the vacation of premises.
Typical events for the termination of the contract fixed for an indefinite time are insolvency of the parties, delay in rent payments, failure to provide the contractually agreed guarantees or pay security deposits, failure to take over the subject of the lease, etc.
The due date for vacating the subject of lease is usually mutually agreed in the lease agreement. In case of the tenant's default, the landlord is entitled to rescind the contract and file a request with the court requesting that the tenant vacate the premises. The length of such process may vary, depending on the activities of the tenant in the procedure, and is impossible to estimate.
A lease can be terminated by state authorities – for instance, in the case of expropriation for public interest or defence purposes. In such situations, the expropriating authority has to pay the appropriate compensation.
The most common structures used to price construction projects are fixed price and price per unit. The most commonly used clause is the so-called 'turnkey price clause' which excludes any potential additional costs which could not be foreseen at the time of concluding the contract.
The builder and the designer are statutorily liable for mistakes made during planning and construction of a project and for the solidity of the construction structure and land defects which arise within ten years after the construction is finished and handed over. Such liability, which applies also vis-à-vis any other person that obtains the relevant construction project, cannot be limited or excluded.
Construction risk is usually managed/mitigated by engaging the services of the construction supervisor, who is entitled to supervise the construction process on the investor's behalf, and by demanding that the contractor take out appropriate insurance and provide appropriate bank or other guarantees for the provision of services and rectification of defects during the warranty period.
For the event that the completion dates are not achieved, the parties usually agree that the investor is entitled to a contractual penalty, the amount of which depends on the period of delay and the value of the investment.
It is common for the investor to seek additional forms of security to guarantee the contractor's performance. Such forms of security entail, inter alia, bank guarantees, contractual penalties, sureties, bills of exchange, parent company guarantees, retention of payments, etc.
It is possible, although uncommon, for contractors to lien a property in the event of the investor's non-payment. Should the parties agree on such an encumbrance, it must be entered into the Land Registry to take effect. The investor may successfully petition that the encumbrance be deleted from the Land Registry on the basis of the appropriate document – ie, a Land Registry permission issued by the contractor or, if the obligations have been fulfilled and the contractor fails to issue such permission, an appropriate judgment of the court.
In cases where the investor has to obtain a construction permit for a project, it also has to obtain a 'fit-for-use' permit issued by the competent administrative unit. Such fit-for-use permit is issued if the construction is conducted in accordance with the relevant construction permit and in accordance with the relevant technical regulations.
The principle tax applicable to transfer of real estate is the real estate transfer tax. Should the transfer involve legal entities that are subject to VAT taxation, the transaction may be taxed by mandatory or voluntary VAT (22%), depending on the type of real estate involved and whether the parties opt to tax the transaction by VAT. VAT is generally tax-neutral, which means that it must formally be paid by the buyer; however, if the buyer is subject to VAT, the buyer may deduct such amount as input VAT and demand reimbursement from the state, making the transaction tax-neutral. Should the parties choose to opt-in and tax the transaction under voluntary VAT, the reverse charge system shall apply, meaning that the amount of VAT is shown on the invoice of the seller, but not paid, also making the transaction tax-neutral.
There are no methods that could be used to mitigate tax liabilities concerning acquisitions of large real estate portfolios.
Occupants are obliged to pay the fee for the use of construction land, unless the parties contractually agree otherwise.
Foreign investors are obliged to pay corporate income tax (19% for legal entities) or personal income tax (25% for natural persons) for rental income in Slovenia. Taxation on rental income applies only to natural persons. In the case of disposition of real property, natural persons are obliged to pay capital gains tax (25%, but decreasing gradually proportional to the length of ownership), unless the conditions for exemption are met. Legal entities are subject to corporate income tax payable every fiscal year, which means there is no income taxation at the moment of disposition.
There are no tax benefits from owning real estate in Slovenia.
The matter is not relevant in this jurisdiction.