Contributed By AEQUITAS
Many amendments intended to introduce new legal institutes and mechanisms, to provide additional benefits and guarantees to employees, to clarify certain procedural issues and to reflect legislative amendments in other spheres have been introduced into the Kazakhstan legislation over the last 12 months. Below are the most important amendments.
Kazakhstan has actively adopted all possible measures to reduce the spread of COVID-19 and reactivate business. The forced lockdowns in 2020 adversely affected the employment market. Many businesses were closed, which led to mass dismissals of employees. To support the citizens, the state has financed a variety of employment programmes, in order to stem the tide of unemployment and support business.
In order to prevent any resurgence in the COVID-19 incidence rate, entrepreneurs were able to resume activities only if they complied with the sanitary rules, and a preliminary readiness inspection with visits by state commission members was stipulated for certain types of facilities (large trading areas).
To regulate the situation under the conditions of constant fluctuations in the incidence rate, Kazakhstan developed a system of criteria for restricting the work of social and economic business facilities. Depending on the situation in a specific region, the required restrictions are promptly put in force, which allows for the prompt reduction of the incidence rate.
Furthermore, Kazakhstan developed special sanitary requirements for business entities with respect to their types of activities, subject to the influence of certain activities on the economy and state security, which vary in strength depending on employees' risk of exposure. General requirements include the necessity for an employer to impose and for employees to comply with a requirement to wear masks, use sanitisers and observe recommended social distancing.
The Kazakhstan labour legislation does not provide any specific distinctions between blue-collar and white-collar employees, and generally all employees enjoy equal rights and bear similar obligations. However, particular provisions might apply to certain categories of employees depending on their conditions of employment (eg, place of work, age or social status).
Additional benefits and guarantees, including special labour conditions, are established for the following categories of employees:
An employer must conclude an employment contract with an employee before he or she commences working for the employer. Admission of an employee to work without an employment contract is prohibited and entails the employer's administrative liability. In the absence of a concluded employment contract, labour relations are deemed to have started from the moment of actual admission of an employee to work, and the employee's labour conditions are determined by the general requirements of the labour legislation.
An employment contract should be executed in writing, in the Kazakh and Russian languages (and, if necessary, in other languages), and there should be two originals, each signed by the employer and the employee. One original copy is given to the employee, and the employer keeps the other. Subject to the latest amendments to the Kazakhstan labour legislation, an employment contract may be concluded in the form of an electronic document using an electronic digital signature.
An employment contract may be entered into for either an indefinite or a definite term. Definite-term employment contracts are entered into in the following cases and under the following terms:
The Kazakhstan labour legislation sets out certain legal requirements pertaining to daily and weekly working hours.
The normal number of working hours for an employee must not exceed 40 hours per week. However, a reduced number of weekly working hours is established for certain categories of employees:
Cumulative work time accounting may be established for an employee, pursuant to which the actual number of working hours in a working week of the employee may exceed the above work time norms. In this case, the work time norms must be complied with on average over an accounting period, which is determined by the employer and may be no more than 12 months.
There is generally a legal limit of eight hours on the length of daily working hours. However, an employee may be established cumulative work time accounting or shift work, pursuant to which the actual duration of the employee's working day may exceed eight hours. Regardless of the applied regime of work, employers must comply with a requirement for there to be a 12-hour break between the working days (shifts) of the employee; therefore, in practice, a working day (shift) of an employee normally does not exceed 11 hours.
The duration of a working day of a person in sideline employment (if such employee works the full work time norm at the primary place of work) must not exceed four hours.
The Kazakhstan legislation provides the possibility to establish part-time working for an employee, ie, to reduce the employee's personal working day and/or number of working days in a working week. Unlike the reduced work time norm, establishment of part-time working for an employee entails the proportionate reduction of the employee's remuneration as compared with other employees working the full work time norm. In all other respects, a part-time employee enjoys the same rights and bears the same obligations as other employees.
Employers may ask employees to work overtime subject to their written consent. Overtime is subject to separate accounting and payment in an increased (1.5) amount. Overtime must not exceed two hours (one hour for employees involved in work with harmful, arduous or hazardous labour conditions) per day, 12 hours per month and 120 hours per year. Disabled persons, underage children and pregnant women are not allowed to work overtime.
Flexible Work Time
The Kazakhstan legislation provides the possibility for an employee to perform work under a flexible work time regime. According to such a regime, the following must be established:
In Kazakhstan, employees are entitled to a salary not lower than the minimum established by law. The minimum monthly salary amount is annually established for the following financial year by the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan on National Budget. At present, the minimum monthly salary must not be less than KZT42,500 (approximately USD99). The minimum monthly salary does not include additional payments or increments, compensatory or social payments, bonuses or other incentive payments, and is paid in proportion to the time worked.
The law does not provide for the automatic adjustment of salaries. However, the minimum salary is reviewed annually to ensure that it keeps pace with consumer prices and that employees’ purchasing power is secured at a minimum level. Private organisations may adjust salaries in line with inflation using the procedures set out in collective bargaining agreements or internal policies.
In 2020, the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of Kazakhstan raised the issue of the necessity to introduce mandatory indexation of salary. However, no specific proposal or draft amendment to legislation has been put forward for discussion yet.
In Kazakhstan, employee incentive systems are determined by employers. Employers may provide bonuses to employees on a one-time basis (eg, bonuses following the annual (or six-month) performance results, according to the results of performing certain work, bonuses in connection with holidays, etc), and in accordance with the labour remuneration and incentive system approved in an organisation.
One-time bonuses not regulated by documents are of a voluntary nature for an employer, while documented incentive systems are binding on employers. Therefore, if an employer establishes any incentive system in its organisation, to protect its interests the bonus payment procedure and conditions must be regulated in detail to the maximum extent possible.
In practice, the amounts of bonuses are often established in proportion to the base salaries of relevant employees. No limitations on the amount of bonuses are established by legislation. However, in the case of establishing regular bonuses to employees (eg, in the form of increments to a monthly base salary for the fulfilment of the employee's tasks), the share of the main part of salary (ie, part received by an employee for the fulfilment of the work time norm) must be not less than 75% of the total salary (without regard to one-time incentive payments) as compared with the variable part (regular incentive payments).
Paid Annual Labour Leave
Under the Kazakhstan legislation, an employer must provide an employee with paid annual labour leave. This leave includes main and additional paid annual labour leaves. The employees are guaranteed to be granted the main leave with a duration of no less than 24 calendar days (for certain professions, for example, for teachers, the minimum duration of the main leave is greater). The durations and cases of granting additional leave are determined by legislation (eg, to disabled employees or employees working under harmful, hazardous or arduous labour conditions).
The leave can be taken continuously or divided into parts by agreement between the employee and employer. One of the parts of the leave must be at least 14 calendar days. Full-time employees and part-time employees have equal rights to paid annual labour leave.
It follows from the title that an employer must pay an employee for paid annual labour leave. The payment is made based on the number of days of work occurring within the period of granted leave, multiplied by the average daily salary of the employee. The average daily salary of the employee is calculated by dividing the employee’s salary accrued over 12 months before granting the leave to the employee by the number of the employee’s days of work during the said period. If the employee has worked for less than 12 months at the time of granting the leave, only the period actually worked by the employee is used for the purposes of calculation.
In Kazakhstan, employees are granted the following types of social leave:
Granting of social leave with the exceptions listed above is the employer's obligation. According to the general rule, social leave is not paid by an employer; however, in certain cases (maternity leave, leave in connection with the adoption of a newborn child, childcare leave until the child reaches the age of three years), employees receive payments from the state social insurance fund.
For a period of temporary incapacity confirmed by a medical opinion in the form established by legislation, an employee is released from work with preservation of employment. Depending on the employee's sickness, an employer may pay a social allowance to the employee during such period. The maximum amount of such allowance is limited by legislation and, according to the general rule, is equal to 15 monthly calculation indices (KZT43,755, or approximately USD102) per month. In certain cases (personnel of diplomatic services, veterans of the Great Patriotic War and persons deemed equal to them) the allowance may be paid in the amount of the employee's full salary for the period of temporary incapacity.
Confidentiality and Non-disparagement
The labour legislation of Kazakhstan does not provide any special provisions concerning confidentiality and non-disparagement, except for the general obligation of employees not to disclose information constituting state secrets or official, commercial or other law-protected secrets coming to their knowledge in connection with the performance of their labour duties. The rights and obligations of an employee and an employer with respect to this issue may be set out and, in practice, are often set out in internal documents of the organisation (employer's acts) and/or in a separate agreement.
In the framework of labour relations with an employer, employees in Kazakhstan bear disciplinary liability (for violating their labour and official duties stipulated by legislation, employment contract, collective bargaining agreement, social partnership agreements or employer's acts) and material liability (for causing material damages to an employer, including any expenses incurred by the employer in connection with a failure to perform or improper performance of obligations by an employee). Other types of liability do not apply to employees under the labour legislation.
Disciplinary liability is the imposition of one of the following disciplinary sanctions on an employee: warning, reprimand, severe reprimand and cancellation of an employment contract. The last sanction is used only in cases expressly stipulated by legislation (eg, repeated failure to perform or improper performance of labour duties after incurring disciplinary liability, presence at a workplace in a condition of alcohol intoxication, absence from a workplace without a valid reason for more than three consecutive hours in a working shift, etc). A mandatory condition for making an employee face disciplinary liability is the employer's compliance with the procedure established by legislation.
As part of an employee's material liability, the employee compensates for the employer's real damages. Material liability of an employee is excluded if the damages were occurred due to force majeure circumstances, extreme necessity, justifiable defence or the employer's violation of conditions ensuring the safety of property.
The labour legislation of Kazakhstan provides the possibility for an employer to enter into a non-compete agreement with an employee. However, the legal regulation of this issue is extremely limited. Specifically, the Labour Code of Kazakhstan determines that a non-compete agreement establishes an obligation of an employee not to take actions capable of causing damage to an employer. The Labour Code is silent as to any specific restrictions which may be imposed on the employee in connection therewith. The relationship between such restrictions and the principle of freedom of labour (the employee's right to be free in selecting labour or agreeing to labour without any discrimination or compulsion, to dispose of his or her own ability to work and to select his or her profession and form of activities) is unclear. In practice, such non-compete agreements are rarely entered into and used mainly by companies with foreign participation.
As regards the requirements for the conclusion of non-compete agreements, the Labour Code establishes that the organisation in question must preliminarily develop and approve a model form of such an agreement and a list of positions of employees eligible to enter into those non-compete agreements.
Please bear in mind that the corporate legislation of Kazakhstan provides restrictions on those activities of the members of the executive body of a legal entity (who are the employees of such legal entity according to the labour legislation) which may harm an employer. Therefore, non-compete agreements with such employees should be entered into in order to settle other issues not regulated by legislation.
The labour legislation of Kazakhstan does not expressly regulate the issue of conclusion of non-solicitation agreements. However, in practice, relevant provisions are normally included by companies in non-compete agreements. In the absence of detailed legal regulation, the non-solicitation conditions are determined by the parties' agreement.
In Kazakhstan, the requirements relating to personal data protection are governed by a relevant local law. The Kazakhstan Constitution determines general approaches with respect to the rights of citizens to privacy, personal and family secrets, honour and dignity protection. As regards the protection of personal data, the Labour Code of Kazakhstan determines that an employer must ensure the protection of the personal data of employees and refers to the above law.
The personal data protection law regulates activities relating to the automated processing of personal data, or manual processing if its nature is similar to automated processing. The law defines ‘personal data’ as any information relating to an identified or identifiable individual who is the subject of the personal data kept electronically or by other means, including paper documents.
Personal data processing includes, without limitation, processes such as the collection, recording, gathering, storage, updating and alteration, retrieval, use, transfer (ie, dissemination, making available and accessible), anonymisation, blocking, deletion and destruction of personal data. Accordingly, the personal data of an employee may contain information including, but not limited to, the following:
The Kazakhstan legislation stipulates the following common requirements for the processing of employees’ personal data based on the rights and freedoms of individuals and citizens.
Kazakhstan's policy in the sphere of labour migration is intended to ensure the protection of the internal labour market and employment of the local population, and the development of the capacity of the workforce in accordance with the economic demands of the country.
Foreign employees (except for employees who are the citizens of EAEU member states, employees working as CEOs or their deputies in Kazakhstan companies with 100% foreign participation, CEOs of the Kazakhstan branches/representative offices of foreign legal entities, and some other employees) may carry out labour activities in the Kazakhstan territory based on a work permit. The size of the foreign labour force engaged in Kazakhstan is subject to a numerical quota. The authorised agency issues work permits in the case of absence of a possibility to satisfy the demand for labour on account of the domestic labour market and in complying with certain statutorily established relationships between foreigners and Kazakhstan citizens on the staff-list number of employees of a company.
The terms for which employment contracts are entered into with foreign employees cannot exceed the effective term of a work permit.
The issued work permits cannot be transferred to other employers and remain in effect only in the territory of a respective administrative and territorial unit. An employer may send a foreign employee on a business trip to a company located in the territory of another administrative and territorial unit for a term of no more than 90 days in total within one calendar year.
The effect of work permits terminates upon their expiration or in the event of their revocation, as well as in the event of the termination of activities or liquidation of an employer and in some other instances. A work permit may be revoked in consequence of hiring foreign employees to positions other than those specified in a work permit or the employer's failure to comply with specific conditions for issuing work permits and/or conditions pertaining to local content in staff.
The Kazakhstan legislation provides the possibility of engaging foreign labour to carry out labour activities under one of the following options.
According to the general rule, a work permit is obtained on a fee-paid basis (tax levy) within the established quota for a specific administrative and territorial unit. For the purpose of annual quota establishment, employers partake in its formation by filing applications for foreign labour engagement.
To determine the procedure and conditions of issuing and/or extending work permits, the Kazakhstan legislation provides for the following categories of employees:
The term of a work permit depends on the category of foreign employees and varies from 90 calendar days to three years, with a possibility to extend it for the same term for employees in the first and second categories.
A foreigner working as a CEO, manager or specialist in a legal entity organised in the territory of a WTO member state located and acting outside Kazakhstan may be transferred to branches/representative offices or subsidiaries of such legal entity organised in Kazakhstan. Such employee must obtain a relevant work permit issued for a term determined by an employment contract, but for no more than three years with the right to extend for one year.
Independent Job Placement
Foreigners may themselves find employment in Kazakhstan without obtaining the above work permits. Such right is confirmed by a certificate specifying that the foreigner's qualifications suits for independent job placement with respect to specialisms in demand (engineers, IT specialists, medical employees and others that possess the highest degree of qualification), which is issued by an authorised governmental agency for a term of no more than three months with the right of extension of the term of employment, but for no more than three years.
The migration legislation provides a visa regime of stay for foreigners in Kazakhstan. Foreign employees and their family members arriving in Kazakhstan obtain a work visa (except for the countries enjoying visa-free entrance).
Employers accepting a foreign employee must inform the migration authority concerning the foreigner's arrival at the place of his or her permanent or temporary residence within three business days. If an employee arrived under the visa-free procedure, it is necessary to execute a temporary residence permit (TRP) for the period of his or her stay in Kazakhstan (within the effective period of a work permit, but, in any case, for a term not to exceed the term of the foreigner's national passport).
Since a foreign employee acquires the status of a tax resident of Kazakhstan, he or she is subject to tax registration with assignment of an individual identification number (IIN).
If the host party fails to perform its obligations to timely notify about the immigrants staying with the host party, take measures on execution of documents for their right to stay in Kazakhstan and ensure their departure from Kazakhstan upon expiration of the permitted period of stay, the Kazakhstan legislation provides for administrative liability. If the host party's liability is established two or more times within 12 consecutive calendar months, this serves as a ground for the authorised agency's refusal to consider invitations of foreigners to Kazakhstan.
The labour legislation recognises trade unions as the employees' representatives in their relations with an employer and the state in the framework of social partnership.
Trade unions are independent in their activities from governmental authorities of all levels, political parties and employers; they are neither controlled by nor accountable to them.
Trade unions are set up under the industry-based principle with the established system of vertical subordination of trade union organisations, ie, small trade unions must join a major industry trade union, which in turn is a member of a national association of trade unions.
The key functions of trade unions are the protection of social and economic rights of employees, participation in social partnership at the national, industry and regional levels, and monitoring the implementation of the adopted resolutions at the organisation's level. Other rights of trade unions may be established by the laws of Kazakhstan, agreements and collective bargaining agreements.
In the absence of a trade union at the employing organisation, the employees may appoint so-called elective representatives. The elective representatives are elected at a general meeting (conference) of employees by the majority of votes of participants. There must be at least two-thirds of the employees attending the meeting (delegates of conference).
The labour legislation allows for joint representation of interests by both a trade union and elective representatives if less than 50% of employees in an organisation are the members of a trade union as compared with the staff-list number of employees. Furthermore, employees who are not trade union members may entrust an elective representative to represent their interests in a specific issue.
Elective representatives of employees may do, among other things, as follows:
The use of collective bargaining agreements has been actively promoted in Kazakhstan since 2008 as part of the presidential campaign "Enter into a collective bargaining agreement". Thanks to the efforts of trade unions and authorised labour agencies, to date, more than 97% of medium-sized and large enterprises are covered by collective bargaining relations.
A collective bargaining agreement is not a mandatory document in an organisation. Only subject to the initiative of employees or the employer must the second party begin negotiations on entering into a collective bargaining agreement. The parties to a collective bargaining agreement are an employer and the employees represented by their representatives.
The content of a collective bargaining agreement is determined by the labour legislation in terms of both its mandatory and optional components. Mandatory conditions include rate setting, labour remuneration, work time duration, occupational health and safety issues, and others. Recommended conditions include additional social guarantees and compensations.
If an employer violates the conditions of a collective bargaining agreement, this may entail application of administrative sanctions to the employer in the form of fines.
Labour relations are terminated with employees in Kazakhstan only based on the grounds and pursuant to the procedure stipulated by legislation.
Grounds for the employment contract termination are:
Lawfulness of dismissal under any of the above grounds is achieved on condition of the presence of the expression of will of one of the parties, relevant legal fact (eg, absence at a workplace for more than three consecutive hours or employer liquidation) and compliance with the established procedure.
Collective staff reduction takes place, as a rule, in the case of mass (more than two employees) staff reduction or employer liquidation.
A number of grounds for employee dismissal require the mandatory notification of the other party. The courts acknowledge that a violation of the notification procedure may entail recognition of a dismissal as illegal. An important aspect in this case is the compliance with the specific procedure for each dismissal ground.
Mandatory notice is stipulated in the following cases:
Compensation in Connection with Loss of Job
An employer makes compensatory payments in connection with the loss of a job in the amount of an average salary for one month in the following cases:
In case of dismissing an employee as a result of reduction of the volume of production, work performed or services provided entailing deterioration of the employer's economic condition, the employer pays compensation in the amount of an average salary for two months.
An employment contract, a collective bargaining agreement or an employer's act may provide for a greater compensatory payment in connection with the loss of job.
As of May 2020, the Kazakhstan legislation no longer contains any regulations similar in their construction to summary dismissal and, accordingly, employee dismissal without a ground or without a sufficient ground is illegal. Please note that last year Kazakhstan excluded a rule from the Labour Code allowing an employer to dismiss an employee at any time, provided that the employee's employment contract contained a special provision. In turn, an employee received a monetary compensation, the amount of which was established by the parties in the employment contract. This rule existed for slightly more than four years and has been excluded due to the protests of trade unions because of the weak position of an employee in the course of entering into a contract.
Dismissal for Serious Cause
The cases where dismissal for serious cause can apply are expressly regulated by the labour legislation and have a similar application procedure. An employer may cancel an employment contract with an employee in cases where the employee:
With respect to almost all of the above grounds, an employment contract is cancelled under the procedure for applying a disciplinary sanction. Such procedure obligates an employer to ask an employee to submit a written explanation of the detected violation. The employee must submit such explanation to the employer within two business days. If the employee refuses to submit an explanation, the employer is entitled to prepare an act of the employee's refusal to submit an explanation and cancel the employment contract. In the case of objective absence of the employee's fault, the employer terminates the dismissal procedure and, vice versa, if the employee's fault has been completely proven, the employment contract is cancelled.
In addition to compliance with the disciplinary procedure, certain cases (eg, strike, corruption, theft) require a judgment or sentence confirming the employee's fault.
The Kazakhstan legislation allows an employee to initiate his or her own dismissal if an employer violates the conditions of the employment contract. In this case, the employee must notify the employer of such fact. In the event of the employer's failure to rectify the violations within seven business days, the employee may cancel the employment contract, having notified the employer in writing at least three business days prior. In this situation, the employer must pay compensation to the employee in the amount of the employee's average salary for one month, unless a greater compensatory payment is stipulated in the employment contract.
Cancellation of an employment contract by agreement of parties seems to be the most favourable ground for the termination of labour relations with employees. Both an employee and an employer may initiate the cancellation of an employment contract.
As a rule, the risk of a subsequent challenge to a dismissal by agreement of the parties is absent or low, which is an advantage for an employer. Often employers who have other grounds to terminate relations with an employee (eg, reduction or dismissal for serious cause) apply the agreement of parties, paying compensation to an employee (sometimes even greater than the compensation stipulated under the existing grounds), thus minimising the risks or expressing their gratitude to the employees for the time worked for a company.
Furthermore, such agreement allows the execution by documents of the conditions and obligations of the parties accompanying the dismissal (return of property and documents of the employer, transfer of files, confidentiality obligations and other issues).
The procedure consists of the following stages (in a situation where the initiator is the employer):
The Kazakhstan legislation ensures the protection of citizens of certain categories in the case of dismissal on the employer's initiative. Thus, an employer is not allowed to dismiss an employee during a period of his or her temporary incapacity or leave (except for cases of employer liquidation, violation of labour duties by the head or deputy head of the executive body of the employer, early termination of powers of the head of the executive body, or employee's absence from work for more than two consecutive months due to temporary incapacity).
The protected categories are:
First of all, the ground for filing a claim of wrongful dismissal is illegal cancellation of an employment contract, including in the absence of a reason for dismissal or insufficiency of the applied ground. One of the grounds often applied in practice is the employer's violation of the dismissal procedure, for example, failure to observe the notice period, disregard of the employee's explanation, etc.
In practice, employees also refer to discrimination resulting in illegal dismissal.
If the unlawfulness of a dismissal is proven, the court reinstates an employee at work and obligates an employer to pay the employee for the forced absence from work, but for no more than six months.
If the dismissal is legal, but the employer mistakenly applied an incorrect ground, a claim is filed to change the wording of the dismissal order. Such mistake does not result in the employee's reinstatement; however, the court obligates the employer to change the dismissal ground.
Prohibition of discrimination in the labour sphere is one of the underlying principles of the Kazakhstan labour legislation. For these purposes, Kazakhstan ratified the Discrimination (Employment and Occupation) Convention of the International Labour Organization.
Nobody can be exposed to any discrimination when implementing labour rights due to origin, social, official and property position, gender, race, nationality, language, attitude to religion, beliefs, place of residence, age or physical defects, or membership of public associations. In certain cases, the Kazakhstan legislation establishes specific preferences and restrictions that, in general, will not be considered discriminatory, in particular:
The practice involving discrimination claims in the labour sphere is not extensive in Kazakhstan, first of all because of the complexities of proving the elements of a violation. The main ground for filing a claim with accusations of discrimination may be the fact of illegal dismissal or disparity in labour conditions between foreign and local employees.
The Kazakhstan legislation provides for mandatory pre-trial consideration of labour disputes with employees. Individual labour disputes (ie, between an employer and a specific employee) are considered by the conciliation board – a permanent body set up within the employing organisation consisting of an equal number of representatives of employees and management of the employer. The following labour disputes are not to be considered by the conciliation board:
An employee (or employer) may apply to court for consideration of an individual labour dispute only if the individual labour dispute has not been settled by the conciliation board or if its resolution is not implemented by one of the parties. Otherwise, the court will deny a relevant claim. The Kazakhstan legislation does not provide for separate proceedings for labour disputes; therefore, such disputes are considered by civil courts.
Collective labour disputes are resolved in accordance with the following procedure. The collective claims of employees are initially considered by an employer (or union of employers). If settlement of a conflict by way of negotiations fails, such dispute is subject to consideration by special pre-trial authorities. Issues which have not been settled at the pre-trial stage are submitted to court.
The mediation board is the first to consider a dispute under the pre-trial procedure. This board is set up by a joint resolution of an employer (or union of employers) and representatives of employees. If there is failure to reach an agreement at the mediation board stage, its work is terminated, and labour arbitration is formed to resolve the dispute. The composition of the labour arbitration and the dispute consideration procedure are determined by an agreement between the employer (or union of employers) and representatives of employees. A state labour inspector must be included in the labour arbitration panel.
Non-state courts (eg, commercial arbitrations and arbitration tribunals) cannot consider labour disputes. Issues that have not been settled at the mandatory pre-trial stage may be submitted for consideration to the state civil courts. The procedure for considering labour disputes with employees is described in 9.1 Judicial Procedures.
According to the general rule, resolutions of pre-trial authorities considering labour disputes are binding on the parties to a dispute. Nevertheless, in fact, a competent court may consider all disputable issues which arise between the parties at the very first stage of a labour dispute.
The Kazakhstan civil procedure legislation allows a prevailing party in the framework of judicial proceedings to apply for compensation by the defeated party of expenses incurred in connection with the payment for the assistance of a representative, if the representative (attorney or legal counsel) is not in labour relations with the prevailing party. However, the amount of potential compensation is limited: with respect to property claims, the total amount of such expenses must not exceed 10% of the satisfied part of a claim; with respect to non-property claims, expenses can be recovered within the reasonable limits; however, they must not exceed 300 monthly calculation indices (KZT875,100, or approximately USD2,035).